South Africa’s illicit economy costs the fiscus at least R84.6 billion a year, according to a study called Shadow State Rising from Frans Cronje Private Clients. BusinessTech reported the figure on 26 September alongside the country’s standing in the Global Organised Crime Index. The study itself was reported by The Common Sense in June 2026.
For businesses, the index quoted below says extortion is now so common that many firms treat it as a regular operating expense, and that counterfeit goods are pervasive.
What the study counts
The study defines the illicit economy as a parallel system of production, trade and finance that operates outside legal, tax and regulatory controls. It lists smuggling, customs fraud, trade misinvoicing, money laundering, counterfeit goods, illegal mining, fuel adulteration, illegal fishing and untaxed business activity. Because none of it is taxed, the losses fall directly on the state.
According to the study, as reported by The Common Sense, R84.6 billion equals 1.0% of GDP, 3.9% of state revenue and about 23.0% of the annual deficit. Tobacco, illegal mining and alcohol are the largest contributors, together costing the fiscus an estimated R74.3 billion of the total each year. The study summary puts unpaid tobacco excise, VAT and corporate tax at R33.3 billion, illegal mining at R23.5 billion in lost royalties, sales and taxes, and illicit alcohol at R17.5 billion. It says illicit brands now make up 60% to 70% of cigarette sales. The remaining R10.3 billion is spread across the other activities on the list. Our own report on British American Tobacco closing its South African plant covers the tobacco side.
Frans Cronje, who leads the firm, told The Common Sense, after a mass shooting in Johannesburg in June that the publication linked to illegal mining, that it should be a warning to lawmakers about the scale of an illicit parallel economy. He described the trade as a shadow state that competes with the legitimate state for money, power and authority. The study argues that these activities are no longer isolated criminal enterprises. It also says the networks undercut legitimate businesses, deter investment and corrupt enforcement systems and border control, and that illegal mining in particular involves territorial control exercised through violence.
This is one firm’s estimate, and the study reports the cost to the fiscus rather than a breakdown of turnover by activity. The Consumer Goods Council of South Africa has put the cost at R68 billion a year using its own research, as we reported in our piece on the R68 billion estimate.
Where the country sits on the Organised Crime Index
The 2025 index is published by the Enact programme, which is funded by the European Union and run by the Institute for Security Studies, Interpol and the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organised Crime. South Africa scored 7.43 out of 10 for criminality, according to a Mail & Guardian report on the index. That is the second-highest score in Africa and the highest of the 13 Southern African countries. BusinessTech put the country seventh out of 193 worldwide.
The Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime, one of the partners behind the index, says South Africa has consistently ranked among the ten most criminal countries since the first index appeared in 2019, citing deeply entrenched illicit markets and persistent problems with governance and law enforcement.
Resilience, the index’s measure of how well a country can withstand and disrupt organised crime, was 5.67. That is the third-highest in Africa and the highest in Southern Africa, according to the Mail & Guardian. BusinessTech reported that the index credits South Africa with a robust legal framework against organised crime, but says governance problems erode public trust. Reported weak points include financial constraints on investigators and strain on law-enforcement agencies from corruption, mismanagement and inefficiency.
Borders, extortion and the private sector
Border enforcement is a recurring theme. BusinessTech said the index describes the counterfeit market as pervasive, and that seizures of counterfeit clothing, footwear, electronics and pharmaceuticals show its scale. It also says illicit trade in excise goods, tobacco and alcohol in particular, remains significant despite the Border Management Authority’s mandate.
For firms operating in the formal economy, the Mail & Guardian quoted the index’s finding that extortion is so entrenched that many businesses now treat it as a regular operating expense, while victims often stay silent out of fear. The same report lists human trafficking, drug and wildlife markets, cybercrime and illicit trade among the country’s main criminal markets.
The index singles out Business Against Crime South Africa (BACSA) as a useful go-between for government and industry. The Consumer Goods Council of South Africa has proposed an Anti-Crime Platform building on BACSA’s work, with the aim of delivering “prevention, disruption, enforcement and measurable outcomes”. It is a proposal, so it has no results to measure yet. More detail is in our report on the Consumer Goods Council’s R68bn warning.
Correction, 28 October 2026: an earlier version of this article described the Global Organised Crime Index as compiled by the Enact programme, gave a global resilience ranking that sources disagree on, and quoted Frans Cronje on a Johannesburg shooting without saying it took place in June. It has been corrected.


