Sunday, 15 November 2026
Markets & Finance

Pepkor fintech merger faces row over missing shareholder vote

Pepkor fintech merger faces row over missing shareholder vote

Pepkor’s plan to merge its Flash fintech business with rival Shop2Shop has upset some of its own directors and at least one large investor because shareholders were never asked to vote on it, according to a Bloomberg report published on 12 October 2026 and carried by Moneyweb. The report says the deal creates a company valued at about R21 billion ($1.3 billion) and marks a major shift in strategy for Africa’s biggest clothing retailer.

For investors in listed companies, the case shows that a large deal in which the chief executive holds a stake can fall short of the JSE’s related-party threshold and so go ahead without a shareholder vote. The vote is the sticking point, not the price.

According to the Bloomberg report, a person familiar with the situation said some directors voted against the July decision because they believed investors should have had a say. That person asked not to be named because the board vote is not public. Pepkor declined to say how many individual directors voted in favour, citing the confidentiality of board proceedings.

Who gets what

When Pepkor announced the deal on 22 July, TechCentral reported that the combined business, provisionally called FintechCo, is valued at R21.3 billion. Pepkor takes a 57.1% controlling stake by injecting R1.57 billion in cash into Shop2Shop and contributing all of Flash, valued at R10.6 billion, in exchange for new shares. According to TechCentral, the cash is used to settle the fintech’s debt.

The remaining 42.9% sits with Shop2Shop’s shareholders. BusinessTech reported that companies related to Shop2Shop founder Peter Berry will hold 24.0% of FintechCo and companies related to Pepkor chief executive Pieter Erasmus will hold 13.2%, with the balance held by Shop2Shop group employees. At the implied valuation, Erasmus’s 13.2% is worth about R2.8 billion, Bloomberg said, adding that this figure could change before the deal is completed.

Pepkor says the combination will expand its payments, lending and merchant-commerce businesses and broaden distribution for its planned digital bank. It plans to list FintechCo separately in the medium term. No listing date has been given.

The conflict of interest

Erasmus is on both sides of the transaction. TechCentral and BusinessTech reported that he holds an indirect minority interest in Shop2Shop through an associated company, a stake that predates his appointment at Pepkor and was previously disclosed in its annual financial statements. Pepkor says Erasmus recused himself from all deliberations and decisions on the transaction.

Aeon Investment Management, a top 30 Pepkor investor, argued that shareholders should have voted on a deal in which the chief executive has what Bloomberg called a clear financial conflict of interest. Aeon holds a 0.4% stake in Pepkor. Its chief executive, Asief Mohammed, was quoted as saying: “It would have gone down better had they done it.” He added: “Seeking shareholder approval would have been good governance.”

Mohammed said Pepkor could have offered a voluntary, non-binding shareholder resolution, letting investors express their views while leaving ultimate responsibility for the transaction with directors. “You could do that, and then you can maybe engage if necessary,” he said.

Why no vote was needed

According to Bloomberg, the transaction does not require shareholder approval under Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) rules because it does not meet the exchange’s threshold for a related-party transaction, which is a deal with someone closely tied to the company, such as a director. TechCentral explained the arithmetic: Erasmus’s interest is below the 35% associate threshold in the JSE listings requirements, so the deal is not classified as a related-party transaction. As a category 2 transaction, it needs no shareholder vote.

Pepkor says it obtained independent valuations of both businesses and a voluntary independent fair-and-reasonable opinion. TechCentral reported that Pepkor’s independent directors concluded the deal is fair and reasonable. These are the company’s own statements about its process, and the Bloomberg report does not test them. The deal also remains subject to regulatory approvals, TechCentral reported, without naming the regulators or giving a completion date.

What the two businesses bring

Cape Town-based Flash serves 170,000 informal traders, enabling them to sell virtual products such as airtime, mobile data and prepaid electricity. Shop2Shop is another payment platform for informal traders and has more than 210,000 users. The combined platform is expected to process more than R200 billion in annual throughput, TechCentral said.

BusinessTech’s figures from the announcement show two profitable businesses. Flash reported revenue of R11.15 billion and earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA, a measure of operating profit) of R900 million for the 12 months to September 2025. Shop2Shop reported revenue of R9.33 billion and EBITDA of R661 million for the 12 months to June 2025. Over three years, Shop2Shop’s EBITDA grew at a compound rate of 85% a year, against 28% for Flash.

TechCentral reported that Shop2Shop’s shareholders keep at least 15% of FintechCo for five years, with put and call options exercisable between years five and eight that give them a route to cash if the listing does not happen.

A share price already under pressure

Bloomberg reported that Pepkor’s stock has dropped 31% this year, compared with a 25% decline on the eight-member FTSE/JSE Retailers Index. The questions from Aeon and the dissenting directors concern process: whether a deal this large, with the chief executive holding a personal stake, should have gone to a shareholder vote even though the rules did not require one.

Related: Pepkor sells three distribution centres for R2bn and retains a 35% stake. Source: Moneyweb (Bloomberg).