Friday, 20 November 2026
Markets & Finance

Morningstar pulls back from South African equities, favours Brazil and Mexico

Morningstar pulls back from South African equities, favours Brazil and Mexico

Morningstar is steering clear of South African shares in its global portfolios because weak economic growth overshadows cheap valuations, according to Sean Neethling, its South African investment head, in a Bloomberg interview carried by Moneyweb on 29 September 2026. The $375 billion asset manager is overweight emerging markets as a whole, with Brazil and Mexico its top picks outside Asia.

What it means for businesses: the view is one fund manager’s, but it points to weak foreign demand for South African shares, which matters most to companies planning a listing. For other businesses the more direct link is borrowing costs, covered below.

The FTSE/JSE All Share Index had fallen more than 4% in dollar terms in 2026 by the time of the report, and is poised for its first annual drop since 2022. Over the same period the MSCI emerging-markets gauge rallied 21%, driven largely by Asian artificial-intelligence companies.

Why Morningstar is looking elsewhere

Neethling oversees about R60 billion ($3.7 billion) in rand- and dollar-based portfolios. He said the problem is growth: “South Africa doesn’t have that growth factor that a lot of other emerging markets have right now.” Moneyweb notes that the economy has expanded by less than 1% a year for more than a decade, and that the fallout of the US-Iran war is weighing on manufacturing, trade and mining output.

Neethling also pointed to technology. “If you look at South Africa at a company-specific level, there’s not many companies that are at the forefront of what’s driving markets right now in artificial intelligence and tech,” Neethling said.

The money is going to Brazil and Mexico. Brazil offers diversified commodity exposure, through companies such as Petrobras and Vale, and well-capitalised banks. Mexico offers what Neethling called an “industrial-staples mix”, with companies such as Coca-Cola Femsa. China remains the firm’s strongest conviction, and South Korea, which has fallen 24% from its 22 June high, is now “attractively priced”, he said.

An overweight position means a fund holds more of a market than its benchmark does.

The Reserve Bank raised rates again

The South African Reserve Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee raised the repo rate by 25 basis points to 7.25% on 23 September 2026, effective 25 September. The decision was unanimous. It was the second increase this year, Moneyweb noted, according to a South African government news agency report on the decision.

Governor Lesetja Kganyago said the inflation outlook faced upside risks as fuel-price shocks intensified and global rates moved higher. Inflation was 4.4%, against a target of 3%. The Bank cut its 2026 growth forecast to 1.2% from 1.4%. Kganyago said it expects a rebound in the second half of the year after a contraction in the second quarter.

Bonds are the exception

Morningstar remains overweight South African government bonds, which Moneyweb says have attractive yields relative to emerging-market peers. “For rand-based investors, South Africa offers really attractive and compelling value, particularly in the bond market, where absolute yields and yields to maturity are among the most attractive in emerging markets, only second to Brazil,” Neethling said.

Foreign investors have been selling South African shares for some time. A Reuters report in June 2025, carried by CNBC Africa, cited Institute of International Finance figures showing foreign investors had pulled $3.7 billion out of South African equities since October 2024, and that the market had suffered annual outflows since 2022.

On borrowing costs, banks usually pass repo rate changes on to prime lending rates, so the September increase is likely to reach overdrafts and term loans. See our report on what the 7.25% repo rate costs businesses. The Markets & Finance section tracks rate and market moves, and Regulatory & Policy covers the decisions behind them.